Elliptical vs Treadmill

Photo of author
Last Update:
Elliptical vs Treadmill

You’re looking to get in shape and are trying to decide which machine is better – an elliptical or a treadmill?

Here’s the low-down on two of the most popular pieces of exercise equipment, helping you make the right choice for your individual goals. Whether you want to lose weight or train for a marathon, we’ve got your covered.

Elliptical machines and treadmills are two of the most popular pieces of exercise equipment available. Both provide a great cardiovascular workout that can help to benefit your overall health. However, they both offer different features, advantages, and disadvantages and choosing the right one for your particular needs is important.

This guide will explore the similarities and differences between an elliptical machine and a treadmill in order to help you make an informed decision when it comes to selecting the best piece of exercise equipment for your home gym or fitness facility.

Benefits of Elliptical Machines

Elliptical machines provide a low-impact workout that still gets your heart rate up. Unlike treadmills, elliptical machines can provide a full-body session, working the upper and lower body at the same time. People with knee or joint issues are often advised to use an elliptical rather than a treadmill, as it is less jarring on the joints.

It’s also an ideal machine for those who want to take part in aerobic exercise but don’t enjoy running due to its repetitive nature. The smooth motion of an elliptical can be more comfortable for some exercisers.

Ellipticals are also convenient — you don’t need any special shoes or clothing and typically don’t sweat heavily, making them perfect for home gyms. Plus, you can adjust the intensity of your workout by changing the resistance level and speed settings.

Benefits of Treadmills

Treadmills offer several advantages that make them a popular choice for home exercise. They are easy to use, require very little maintenance, and can help you burn hundreds of calories in a short period of time. Many treadmills come with preset programs and electronic displays that track your progress, so you can easily monitor your performance. Additionally, most treadmills come with adjustable speed settings that allow you to customize your workouts for maximum intensity.

Benefits of running on a treadmill include improved cardiovascular health, increased muscle tone, better endurance and energy levels, reduced stress levels, and improved mental health. It also can provide faster weight loss when combined with proper diet and nutrition as compared to other cardiovascular exercises.

In addition to these physical benefits, the psychological effects of running on a treadmill should not be overlooked. Running outdoors or on a treadmill provides an excellent opportunity for stress relief because it is easier to concentrate on the physical activity than worrying about work or personal issues while exercising. Furthermore, completing your workout gives you an immense sense of accomplishment; this will help motivate you to continue exercising even when the going gets tough.

Differences between Elliptical Machines and Treadmills

When deciding between a treadmill and an elliptical, there are a few things to consider. While treadmills and ellipticals both provide an effective, low-impact cardiovascular workout, there are several key differences between them:

Muscles Worked – Elliptical machines target an upper body workout as well as lower body. You’ll work both your quadriceps, hamstrings, and glutes without putting excessive strain on your knees and ankles. Treadmills only involve the lower body, putting a greater amount of strain on your joints.

Stride – The stride on an elliptical is longer than the stride of a treadmill belt and easier on the joints because you’re more likely to move in a natural motion without abrupt stops or starts. With treadmills, you must adjust the belt speed manually whereas some ellipticals allow you to make adjustments automatically with quick touch buttons.

Calorie Burning Ability – Both machines allow you to burn calories quickly if used correctly; however, ellipticals may offer the edge here since it requires somewhat more effort for pushing against the arms as well as pushing against with legs during full strides. This can result in slightly higher calorie burn than running or walking alone on a treadmill.

Cost – Treadmills tend to be cheaper than other fitness equipment because they only involve one movement pattern with no user adjustment necessary for different exercises or muscle targets; this makes them ideal for beginners who do not require all of the bells and whistles of advanced machines like those found on many ellipticals.

Which Machine Is Better for Weight Loss?

When deciding whether to use an elliptical or a treadmill for weight loss, it is important to consider your individual needs and goals. An elliptical is generally considered a better choice for weight loss because it is low-impact and works the entire body in one motion. On the other hand, a treadmill offers more intensity and speed, allowing you to burn more calories in less time. Additionally, many modern treadmills come with automated programs that allow you to adjust your workouts based on your level of fitness or goals.

The bottom line is that both machines can be effective for weight loss when used correctly and regularly. To get the most out of your workouts you should combine aerobic exercise on either machine with strength training and a healthy diet for best results. You may find that one machine suits you better than the other so it’s important to try them out before committing to any one routine or method of exercise. An experienced personal trainer can help guide you through your options so that you can make an informed decision about which is the best machine for you.

Which Machine Is Better for Cardio Workouts?

Cardio workouts are an important part of an overall fitness regime, and an array of machines are available to help with these exercises. Elliptical trainers and treadmills are some of the most popular choices when it comes to cardio workouts. Both offer advantages and challenges depending on your goals, so it is important to understand the difference between each machine before choosing which one is right for you.

The elliptical machine allows users to have a low impact workout while still providing effective cardiovascular exercise. It requires minimal coordination, making it perfect for those who might be weary of more technical equipment. Additionally, the elliptical helps improve balance and stability as well as provide a whole body workout. Given its low impact nature, it is also a good option for individuals with joint issues that may be exacerbated by high-impact cardio exercises.

Treadmills offer a slightly different form of exercise than an elliptical. While running on a treadmill is much like running outdoors, they provide many stability-enhancing features that make them safer than regular road running. They also allow you to set speed, incline and other workout levels in order to customize your exercise plan each day according to your individual needs or goals. With treadmills there may be more potential for injury due to its higher impact nature, but proper usage and maintenance helps mitigate any risks associated with using this type of equipment.

When considering which type of machine is better for cardio workouts, it really depends on your individual preferences and needs — what works best for one person may not necessarily work best for another person even if their goals are similar! As with any exercise regimen or program, remember to always consult your physician before starting a new routine in order to ensure that you remain safe during the process — they will be able to help guide you in making the best suggestion as pertains specifically towards yourself or lifestyle!

Which Machine Is Better for Joint Health?

Finding the right exercise equipment can be a daunting task, especially if you have been experiencing joint pain and stiffness. Two popular pieces of cardio equipment are elliptical and treadmill machines, but it can be difficult to decide which one is better for joint health.

The main difference between an elliptical and a treadmill is the way in which the user moves. An elliptical machine requires a no impact movement pattern by pedaling in an oval pattern with your feet firmly on the pedals, while on a treadmill you move in a forward or backward motion with your feet leaving the belt momentarily with each stride. This movement comes at a cost – namely lower body joint stress from the impact of landing on hard surfaces experienced while running or walking on a treadmill. The good news is that elliptical exercise reduces this joint-stressing impact without sacrificing the intensity of your workout since you are still continuously propelling yourself forward despite not having to lift up off of the surface.

Elliptical guarantees an all-around lower body workout with minimal stress or injury risk for any age group as long as proper form is followed. Additionally, most models also feature arm components which further adds to its multi-dimensional workout potential – all with no harmful stress from hard surfaces like those produced by running or jogging outdoors or even walking indoors on traditional treadmills.. On the other hand, treadmills provide more variable terrain options depending upon the model with everything from flat roads to mountainous hills allowing for users to increase their cardio performance over time.

When considering which option might work best for joint health it is important to remember that there isn’t one size fits all solution so consider consulting your doctor before making any decision on specific machines – as well as doing research online and taking advantage of retail offerings like trying out both types in store showrooms prior to purchase. Ultimately whichever option suits you best should be based upon your comfort level and what kind of activity you enjoy most while getting in shape!


In conclusion, there are advantages and disadvantages to both ellipticals and treadmills. Ultimately, it is important to consider all factors before deciding which machine provides the best value for your individual fitness needs. Though both types of exercise machines offer diverse benefits, treadmills typically provide a more intense workout due to its higher cardiovascular demands.

However, if joint stress is an issue for you, then an elliptical may offer a better solution as these machines provide a lower impact movement that does not involve weight bearing. In the end it depends on your goals and lifestyle as to which type of machine will be right for you.

Photo of author
Hi, I'm William Greco, a 28-year-old Personal Trainer and Performance Nutritionist based in Mesa, Phoenix, AZ. With 8 years of experience as a Personal Trainer and 4 years as a Performance Nutritionist, I'm passionate about helping my clients achieve their fitness goals. At Fitness Koala, I provide recommendations on a variety of training equipment, including Treadmills, Indoor Rowers, Stationary Bikes, and more.

Leave a Comment